René Seerden (Ed.), comparative administrative law, 4th edition?

Author:Irina Alexe, PhD
René Seerden (ed.), Comparative Administrative Law, 4th Edition 97
Irina ALEXE, PhD
Bucharest, 2018
Intersentia1 Publishing released, in January 2018, the 4th edition of the
Comparative Administrative Law. Bearing the subtitle Administrative Law of the
European Union, Its Member States and the United States, the volume makes a
comparative analysis of the most important aspects of the administrative law at the
level of the European Union, with a case study based on several member states of
the European Union such as France, Germany, Netherlands or the United
Kingdom, as well as at the level of the United States of America. We should
underline that the first edition of this work was published in 2002, the second one
in 2007, and the third one in 2012.
The editor of this fourth edition of this volume, René Seerden, is associated
professor at the Law Faculty of Maastricht University, where he teaches, within the
Public Law Department, Comparative Administrative Law and Environment Law.
Also, he is Administrative Judge in the Districtual Court in Limburg, Netherlands.
This volume, a veritable instrument in Comparative Law, necessary and useful
both in the field of education and in the field of research, but especially in practice,
succeeds in following the rapid development in the Administrative Law, both in
the aforementioned states and at the level of the European Union, emphasizing
both common and differentiating elements. The editor himself makes a point, in
the introductive section, that, in his opinion, these very differences contribute to a
more active and vivid lecture of the volume (p.2).
Intersentia, 2018, xxix + 438 pp; ISBN: 978-1-78068-630-1.
Research associate, „Acad. Andrei Rdulescu” Legal Research Institute of Romanian Academy;
Doctor of Juridical Sciences of the University of Bucharest; principal areas of interest: Administrative Law,
Constitutional Law and European Law; The author would like to thank Mr. Bogdan
opan for the support offered in translating the article in English. The review was published in Romanian in
Romanian Review of European Law, no. 1/2018.
1 Further details containing this volume can be found at
Law Review vol. VIII, issue 1, Januar
-June 2018, pp. 97-100
We consider that this work has a high added-value, relevant through the
importance granted to this field, as well as due to the fact that, under the
coordination of the editor, the contributions within the volume were made by
vernacular specialists, acclaimed not only in the states where they come from, but
also at the international level. This a detail to be appreciated, emphasized both in
the rich bibliography mentioned in every chapter of the volume, both in the
footnotes and at the end of every chapter.
Starting with a preface, like in the case of every edition of the volume, the
work is structure2 in eight parts: a first part consists of the presentation of the
intriductory remarks of the editor, followed by six chapters, one dedicated to the
European Union, respectively each of the aforementioned states, while a last part is
dedicatied to the comparative remarks made by the author, following the structure
of the chapters, hence realising a unitary structure of the volume.
As stated by the editor in the introductory remarks, the volume aspires to
contribute to a crossborder understanding of the diverse adminsitrative regimes,
aiming at emphasizing, in every chapter, while each chapter aims at emphasizing
the particularities at the level of the European Union, respectively of the states
whose legislation is analyzed, aiming in 8 items, identified (p. 2-3) as follows:
1. What is Administrative Law?
2. Who is administrating?
3. Which instruments are available for the administration?
4. Which (formal) rules/principles (written or unwritten) govern
administrative actions?
5. Access to (administrative) courts against administrative actions/decisions.
6. Enforcement by the administration.
7. Financial liability of the administration for (un)lawful actions.
8. Recent and future developments and conclusions.
The first chapter, analyzing the Administrative Law in France, was realized by
Jean-Bernard Auby, Lucie Cluzel-Metayer and Lamprini Xenou and is treating, in
six distinct sections (Definition and Scope of Administrative Law; Legal Design of
the Administration, Substance of the Administrative Powers and Administrative
Acts; Administrative Norms and Administrative Legality; Administrative
Litigations and Protection of the Citizens against the Administration; Conclusions),
accompanied, as previously mentioned, by a vast relevant bibliography.
The second chapter, realized by Hermann Punder and Anika Klafki, treating
the particularities of the German Administrative Law, is structured in eight
sections, as follows: the Concept of Administrative Law; Administrative
Organization; Administrative Acts and Other Instruments of the Administration;
Rules and Principles governing Administrative Action; Review of Administrative
2 The contents of this volume can be found at
René Seerden (ed.), Comparative Administrative Law, 4th Edition 99
Acts, Enforcement of Administrative Acts by the Administration, Non-contractual
Liability for Administrative Acts, Recent and Future Developments. This chapter
as well is accompanied by a vast and relevant bibliography.
The Administrative Law in Netherlands is analyzed in the third chapter of the
volume, by the editor, René Seerden, together with Danielle Wenders, and
contains, apart from the seven sections, an impressive bibliography, as well as an
annex containing Key Provisions of General Administrative Law. The sections are
analyzing: introductive aspects, who has administrative powers; What Instruments
are Available to the Administration; What are the Norms with Which the
Administration has to Comply; Legal Protection against Administrative Action;
Enforcement of Administrative law; Conclusions.
The following chapter, which analyzes the particularities of the Administrative
Law in the United Kingdom, realized by Katharine Thompson, contains seven
sections (introductive notions, the Distribution of Administrative Powers, How are
Administrative Decisions made, Non Judicial Redress of Grievances, Judicial
Review, Liability of Public Administration, Conclusions), as well as the afferent
bibliography, and an annex containing section 31 of the Senior Courts Act 1981.
The chapter which analyzes the European Administrative Law (or, more
precisely, of the European Union), realized by Rolf Ortlep and Rob
Winddershoven, contains eight sections accompanied by an eloquent bibliography,
in which are detailed the particularities aiming at: introductory remarks; on Who
has Administrative Powers, What Instruments are Available in the Administration,
at the level of the European Union, at the national level, respectively the Direct and
Indirect Effect of Union Law; How is European Law enforced, What are the Norms
with Which the Administration has to Comply; What Legal Protection is There
against Administrative Action, What Leal Protection is There against
Administrative Action; Remedies at the National Level, Non-Contractual Liability,
and conclusions.
The particularities of the Administrative Law in the United States are analyzed
by Jeffrey S. Lubbers in a distinct chapter, structured in six sections in which are
detailed aspects concerning general issues such as: What is Administrative Law in
the United States; the Constitutional Structure; the American Administrative
Process; Judicial Review of Administrative Action; Means of Enforcement; Review
and Prognosis. This chapter as well contains a vast and relevant bibliography of
the field of study.
Considering the analyses made by the authors of the six aforementioned
chapters, and with a permanent attention for structuring the content by the eight
items already mentioned, René Seerden makes, in the last chapter of the volume, a
short introduction, subsequently subtracting its comparative remarks in eight
different sections concerning Administrative Law, the Administration, Legal
Instruments, Rules and Principles, Access to Court and (Prior) Out-of-Court
Proceedings, Enforcement by the Administration, and Developments and
Conclusions. The synthesizing power of the author of this last chapter, editor of the
volume, needs to be emphasized, as he underlines, in a brief yet comprehensive
manner, the evolutionary processes of the Administrative Law.
In order to understand not only the very complex and vast field of the
Administrative Law, but also the European evolutions in this field, and of the other
states analyzed within the volume, we consider that this volume is relevant for the
professionals, theorists or practitioners of the Romanian administrative law, but
also for students or even for the subjects of the administration, the citizens. We
recommend this work wholeheartedly, being convinced by the fact that reading
this volume helps clarifying the used concepts and leads to a better understanding
not only of the national Administrative Law systems, but also of the existing
reports between the National Law of the Member States and the Law of the
European Union.
We think that knowing the essence of this volume, both by the decision-
makers and the citizens is extremely important, especially in relation with the eight
aforementioned items and to the cross-border comprehension of the notions. This
should prove particularly useful in the context in which the Romanian
Administrative Code is currently in the parliamentarian procedure, with a debate
to follow, with a text intending to introduce new concepts, new relationships, or to
redefine the existing one within the Romanian administrative system.